On this page
What's next
Earn a high-yield savings rate with JG Wentworth Debt Relief
In today’s financial landscape, homeowners have various options for tapping into their home’s equity. Two increasingly popular choices are Home Equity Agreements (HEAs) and Home Equity Lines of Credit (HELOCs). While both allow homeowners to access their home’s value, they function quite differently and serve distinct purposes.
What is a Home Equity Agreement?
A Home Equity Agreement represents a relatively new financial innovation in the housing market. Unlike traditional lending products, an HEA isn’t a loan at all – it’s an investment agreement. When you enter an HEA, you receive a lump sum of cash in exchange for a portion of your home’s future value.
The process works like this: An investment company provides you with immediate cash, typically between 10% and 30% of your home’s current value. In return, you agree to share a percentage of your home’s appreciation (or depreciation) when you sell the property or when the agreement term ends, usually within 10 years.
Key Features of HEAs
- No monthly payments required
- No interest charges since it’s not a loan
- Shared risk if property values decline
- Usually requires 20% or more remaining equity after the agreement
- Terms typically range from 10-30 years
- Can be settled through sale, refinancing, or buying out the investor’s position
Understanding HELOCs
A Home Equity Line of Credit functions more like a traditional lending product. It’s essentially a revolving credit line secured by your home’s equity. Think of it as a credit card that uses your house as collateral.
With a HELOC, you’re approved for a maximum credit limit based on your home’s value, credit score, and other financial factors. You can draw from this credit line during a set period (typically 10 years), making interest-only payments on the amount you’ve borrowed. After the draw period ends, you enter the repayment phase, where you must pay back both principal and interest.
Key Features of HELOCs
- Variable interest rates that fluctuate with market conditions
- Monthly payments required
- Only pay interest on what you actually borrow
- Usually requires good credit and stable income
- Potential tax deductions for interest paid
- Can be frozen or reduced if home values decline
Compare Home Equity Options
Compare Home Equity Options
Deep Dive: Key Differences Between HEAs and HELOCs
Ownership Structure
HEA: When you enter into an HEA, you’re essentially selling a portion of your home’s future value. The investment company becomes a stakeholder in your property’s appreciation or depreciation.
HELOC: You maintain full ownership of your home, but you’re using it as collateral for a loan. The lender has no stake in your property’s future value beyond securing the loan.
Cost Structure
HEA: Instead of interest payments, your cost is tied to home appreciation. If your home value increases significantly, you might end up paying more than you would with a HELOC. However, if your home value decreases, you share the loss with the investor.
HELOC: Costs are more straightforward – you pay interest on borrowed amounts at a variable rate. While this might seem more predictable, rising interest rates can significantly increase your payments.
Qualification Requirements
HEA: Often more flexible with credit requirements since payment ability is less critical (no monthly payments). However, properties must typically show strong appreciation potential.
HELOC: Stricter credit requirements, including:
- Minimum credit score (usually 620+)
- Debt-to-income ratio requirements
- Proof of steady income
- Clean payment history
Risk Profile
HEA: Primary risks include:
- Potentially high cost if property values surge
- Reduced profit when selling the home
- Limited ability to tap additional equity while agreement is active
HELOC: Main risks include:
- Variable interest rates that could increase significantly
- Risk of foreclosure if payments aren’t made
- Potential for negative amortization in some cases
- Possible freezing of credit line if home values drop
Making the Right Choice: When to Choose Each Option
Consider an HEA if:
- You have irregular income or are self-employed
- You want to avoid monthly payments
- Your credit score might not qualify for traditional financing
- You’re comfortable sharing future appreciation
- You need a large lump sum immediately
- You want to avoid taking on additional debt
Consider a HELOC if:
- You have stable income and good credit
- You prefer traditional borrowing arrangements
- You need flexibility in how much you borrow
- You’re confident in your ability to make monthly payments
- You want to maintain full ownership of future appreciation
- You need ongoing access to funds rather than a lump sum
Market Impact and Future Considerations
The choice between an HEA and HELOC can have long-term implications for your financial future. Housing market conditions play a crucial role in determining which option might be more advantageous.
In rising markets, HELOCs might be preferable as you maintain all the upside potential. However, in uncertain markets, an HEA’s shared-risk model could provide valuable downside protection.
Expert Tips for Decision-Making
- Analyze your local real estate market trends
- Calculate your home’s realistic appreciation potential
- Consider your income stability and credit profile
- Evaluate your long-term plans for the property
- Compare total costs under different market scenarios
- Consult with financial advisors familiar with both products
The Bottom Line
Both HEAs and HELOCs serve valuable purposes in the home equity market, but they’re fundamentally different tools. HEAs offer flexibility and payment-free access to equity but require sharing future appreciation. HELOCs provide traditional borrowing benefits with more stringent requirements and regular payments.
Your choice should align with your financial situation, risk tolerance, and long-term goals. Consider seeking professional advice to understand how each option might impact your specific circumstances.
Remember, whether you choose an HEA or HELOC, you’re making a significant financial decision that affects one of your most valuable assets – your home. Take time to understand all terms, conditions, and potential outcomes before proceeding with either option.
About the author
Recommended reading for you
*** JGW Connects, LLC is an independent, advertising-supported comparison site and marketing lead generator and does not play a role in decisioning for any of the third party products advertised on this webpage. JGW Connects, LLC and the JG Wentworth Company family of companies are not affiliated with the companies advertising on this webpage. You are not charged for our services. JGW Connects, LLC may receive a referral fee or other affiliate fee for connecting you with these third-party companies or upon you contracting with a third-party company. We do not make any guarantees that these are the only providers in the marketplace, or that their products or services will meet your needs. The products and services presented to you may or may not be the best, or only options, available.
JGW Connects does not provide any of the products or services advertised and does not make any decisions regarding your eligibility for those products or services. All decisions regarding approval or denial of a particular product or service are the responsibility of the participating company and will vary based upon your particular financial situation, and criteria determined by the company to whom you are matched. Not all consumers will qualify for the advertised rates and terms.